• Crypto Prices
    • CoinDesk Market Index
    • TV & Videos
    • Newsletters
    • Podcasts
    • WhiteLayersIconConsensus Magazine
    • Learn
    • Bitcoin Calculator
    • Consensus
    • Webinars
    • Indices
    • About
    • Markets
    • Companies
    • Technology
    • Web3
    • Policy
    • Sponsored Content
    Upcoming event
    Consensus 2023 Nav BarSave $600+ on Consensus!
  • TV & Videos

    TV & Videos

    • First Mover
    • The Hash
    • All About Bitcoin
    • Money Reimagined
    • Community Crypto
    • Consensus 22 Videos
    • View all shows

    Watch On

    • Twitter

      Twitter

    • Facebook

      Facebook

  • Newsletters

    Sign up for our newsletters

    Learn More
    UncheckedCheckbox

    Crypto Investing Course

    Be a smarter, safer investor in eight weeks.

    UncheckedCheckbox

    The Node

    The biggest crypto news and ideas of the day.

    UncheckedCheckbox

    First Mover

    The latest moves in crypto markets, in context.

    UncheckedCheckbox

    Money Reimagined

    The transformation of value in the digital age.

    UncheckedCheckbox

    Crypto Long & Short

    News and analysis for the professional investor.

    UncheckedCheckbox

    State of Crypto

    Probing the intersection of crypto and government.

    UncheckedCheckbox

    Valid Points

    How Ethereum's evolution impacts crypto markets.

    UncheckedCheckbox

    Crypto for Advisors

    What financial advisors need to know about crypto.

    By signing up, you will receive emails about CoinDesk products and you agree to ourterms & conditionsandprivacy policy.

  • Podcasts

    Podcasts

    • The Hash
    • Markets Daily
    • Money Reimagined
    • The Breakdown, With NLW
    • Carpe Consensus
Coindesk Logo
  • Consensus

    Consensus

    • Go to Consensus 2023 Site
    • Consensus 2022 Videos
    • Powered By Consensus Content
  • Indices

    Indices

    • Bitcoin Price Index (XBX)
    • Ether Price Index (ETX)
    • Basic Attention Token Price Index (BTX)
    • Bitcoin Cash Price Index (BCX)
    • Cardano Price Index (ADX)

  • Crypto Prices
  • CoinDesk Market Index

  • TV & Videos
  • Newsletters
  • Podcasts
  • WhiteLayersIconConsensus Magazine
  • Learn
  • Bitcoin Calculator
  • Consensus
  • Webinars
  • Indices
  • About

  • Markets
  • Companies
  • Technology
  • Web3
  • Policy

  • Sponsored ContentChevrone Right Icon

Upcoming event
Consensus 2023 Nav BarSave $600+ on Consensus!
  • Markets

    Markets

    • Bitcoin
    • Ether
    • Altcoins
    • Trading
    • First Mover
  • Companies

    Companies

    • FTX Downfall: Full Coverage
    • Celsius
    • NFTs
    • Terra
    • Business
  • Policy

    Policy

    • Regulation
    • Crypto
    • Sanctions
    • SEC
    • Law
  • Technology

    Technology

    • Blockchains
    • Ethereum
    • DeFi
    • Stablecoins
    • Hacks
  • Web3

    Web3

    • Yuga Labs
    • NFTs
    • Metaverse
    • Dao
    • Gaming
  • Learn

    Learn

    • NFTs
    • Bitcoin
    • Ethereum
    • Cryptocurrency
    • Investing

    Crash Courses

    • Bitcoin 101
    • DeFi 101
    • Ethereum 101
    • NFT 101
    • Price Data 101
  • Consensus Magazine

    Consensus Magazine

    • Crypto 2023
    • Most Influential
    • Tax Week
    • Trading Week
    • IDEAS Week

    Most Recent Issue

    CoinDesk - Unknown
  • Sponsored Content

    Sponsored Content

    • Gate.US
    • abra
    • Matrixport
    • SocialGood
    • Tron
Bitcoin
$22,973.61+0.86%
Ethereum
$1,636.25+0.62%
Binance Coin
$328.73+1.29%
XRP
$0.39666156-0.79%
Binance USD
$0.99972975-0.00%
Aptos
$15.29+3.86%
Cardano
$0.38700000-1.08%
Dogecoin
$0.09094266-1.02%
Polygon
$1.23+3.43%
Stellar
$0.08961500-0.52%
Solana
$23.21+0.17%
Shiba Inu
$0.00001412-3.19%
Crypto.com
$0.07957728+1.11%
Polkadot
$6.65-0.19%
Litecoin
$99.46+3.67%
Chainlink
$6.97+0.19%
Uniswap
$6.81+0.10%
Avalanche
$20.07+0.99%
Tron
$0.06427895+1.68%
Cosmos
$14.47+1.49%
Wrapped Bitcoin
$22,947.94+0.81%
Quant
$137.97+1.44%
Ethereum Classic
$22.52+0.04%
Monero
$167.26+1.08%
dYdX
$2.97-2.19%
Stepn
$0.51771035+1.02%
Internet Computer
$5.58+0.79%
Bitcoin Cash
$132.95+0.40%
Load Network
$2.33+13.74%
ApeCoin
$5.68+0.50%
Curve DAO Token
$1.06+1.68%
Filecoin
$5.28+0.63%
NEAR Protocol
$2.34-1.55%
Algorand
$0.26073665+1.40%
Hedera
$0.06911347-0.42%
VeChain
$0.02417948+1.48%
Decentraland
$0.72284299-0.13%
Fantom
$0.54014067-3.21%
Aave
$87.04+2.02%
The Graph
$0.14926432+16.59%
The Sandbox
$0.71669655-0.36%
Luna Classic
$0.00018325-1.78%
Axie Infinity
$10.89+0.07%
EOS
$1.07-0.72%
Flow
$1.10-0.23%
Elrond
$45.58+2.44%
Theta
$1.12+3.30%
Tezos
$1.16+0.08%
Synthetix
$2.87+13.17%
Paxos Dollar
$0.99945518+1.42%
NEO
$8.87+1.47%
Bitcoin SV
$42.64-1.53%
Chiliz
$0.13967512+0.75%
Immutable X
$0.93729160+7.69%
PancakeSwap
$4.49+3.53%
eCash
$0.00003701-0.05%
Dash
$64.02+6.05%
BitTorrent
$0.00000075+1.49%
Maker
$714.72+3.70%
Mina
$0.82057477+7.32%
IOTA
$0.24089801-0.98%
FTX Token
$1.98+5.94%
Optimism
$2.98+6.46%
Convex Finance
$6.52+6.41%
Zcash
$44.23+1.70%
Fetch.ai
$0.56363038+29.65%
Compound
$53.82+3.39%
THORChain
$1.79+1.02%
PAX Gold
$1,870.68+0.35%
Zilliqa
$0.02932966+2.58%
Loopring
$0.37422462+1.60%
Enjin
$0.46236997+0.92%
Terra 2.0/LUNA
$2.09-0.28%
Mask Network
$4.34-3.83%
Nexo
$0.75625212-1.11%
Basic Attention Token
$0.27709000-2.36%
Stacks
$0.30370017+2.73%
Gala
$0.05288375+0.85%
Ethereum Name Service
$15.26+2.13%
Woo Network
$0.23793059+10.66%
Kava.io
$0.96755057+0.93%
Celo
$0.79180967-0.41%
Ravencoin
$0.03139403+7.42%
NEM
$0.04108325+0.67%
Sushiswap
$1.47+3.72%
Decred
$23.21+2.22%
Bitcoin Gold
$17+1.60%
Kusama
$35.50-0.56%
TerraUSD
$0.03180876-6.16%
IoTeX
$0.03274613+3.01%
Injective Protocol
$3.92+7.77%
Qtum
$2.85+2.64%
Audius
$0.29647875+12.27%
Oasis Network
$0.05669302+4.67%
Yearn Finance
$7,637.13+1.35%
Amp
$0.00490691+3.41%
Waves
$2.74+3.53%
Band Protocol
$2.12+1.71%
Moonbeam
$0.46021824+0.63%
Ribbon Finance
$0.25788000+0.45%
0x
$0.24801689-0.23%
Celsius
$0.57990162-7.82%
Ankr
$0.03001232+6.54%
UMA Protocol
$2.12+2.92%
Livepeer
$9.47+8.43%
OMG Network
$1.67+0.46%
NuCypher
$0.15943225-1.52%
ICON
$0.22788079-3.38%
Siacoin
$0.00392666+7.95%
MetisDAO
$35.70-1.65%
Polymath Network
$0.17958559+0.15%
SafePal
$0.55133449+0.88%
Wax
$0.07802838-1.10%
Cartesi
$0.17323989+9.01%
DigiByte
$0.01073548+2.89%
Lisk
$1.14-3.61%
Numeraire
$26.55+24.96%
iExec RLC
$2.20+11.97%
SXP
$0.31003714+0.19%
Skale
$0.03866825+1.06%
Voyager Token
$0.51091333+4.84%
Secret
$0.78466717+2.55%
Smooth Love Potion
$0.00321396+2.10%
Nervos Network
$0.00376925+2.89%
Civic
$0.12102590+3.70%
Keep Network
$0.21294010+2.33%
Spell Token
$0.00084321+3.43%
Nano
$0.86936296+3.27%
Aragon
$2.91+2.11%
Syscoin
$0.17187415+5.52%
COTI
$0.09887559+0.16%
Vulcan Forged PYR
$4.20+3.69%
Ren
$0.10005650-1.00%
Serum
$0.36850690+2.85%
Chromia
$0.16657059+1.12%
Augur
$8.51-0.46%
Alchemy Pay
$0.01882790-0.07%
MOBOX
$0.57674705+3.65%
Steem
$0.22950301+3.35%
Joe
$0.26411456+24.47%
Bancor
$0.46787811+5.94%
Request
$0.11299785+4.48%
WazirX
$0.18647734+0.16%
XYO Network
$0.00639000-1.25%
NKN
$0.11058745+4.95%
Yield Guild Games
$0.34103765+17.03%
Ampleforth Governance
$4.07+12.77%
Storj
$0.42215974-0.44%
Orchid
$0.09994645+4.66%
Stormx
$0.00621263+0.10%
Sun Token
$0.00646237+8.26%
Verge
$0.00316906+0.91%
Moonriver
$9.16+2.27%
Polkastarter
$0.46278037+2.89%
district0x
$0.05868949+153.26%
Alpaca Finance
$0.28701536+2.95%
Raydium
$0.29100299+18.73%
Index Chain
$0.05681268+3.54%
Enzyme
$25.72+7.32%
JasmyCoin
$0.00740955+11.81%
CLV
$0.07783407+5.05%
Mirror Protocol
$0.17372766-0.83%
Harvest Finance
$39.67+5.24%
Quickswap
$57.27+3.81%
Samoyedcoin
$0.00450587-0.63%
Kyber Network
$0.88878391+0.15%
SuperRare
$0.16932127+5.42%
Quantstamp
$0.01540000-0.39%
Star Atlas DAO
$0.34789284+3.02%
SingularDTV
$0.000402100.00%
Tether
$0.99983038-0.03%
USD Coin
$0.99980553-0.02%
Dai
$0.99937070-0.02%
PlayIconNav
Crypto Prices CoinDesk Market Index

Sponsored Content

CoinDesk - Unknown

CBDCs Are Coming. Privately Created Stablecoins Need to Come Faster

AccessTimeIconNov 22, 2021
Facebook iconLinkedin iconTwitter icon
CoinDesk - Unknown

CoinDesk Staff

The idea of fiat currency is something of a historical anomaly.

Around 5,000 years ago, shiny metals became a store of value for goods and services. Those were soon fabricated into standardized tokens, becoming media of exchange. It wasn’t for another 2,000 years, though, that anyone engraved the king’s face on those tokens. Money derived from the producers, not governments. So why should governments today have a monopoly on their local money supply?

Moreover, why should that be a controversial question? The Federal Reserve is not the United States’ first attempt at a central bank – it’s the fourth. The 1913 founding of the Fed culminated a 50-year concentration of banking power, a process that started with the National Banking Act of 1863 that Congress had passed to help fund the Civil War. Prior to that point, banks and private businesses were free to issue their own currencies. It was chaotic and there were a lot of failures, but the system worked for 25 years and provided individuals with choice.

Even after the act was passed, not everyone trusted the new national dollar. Local banks, railroads and state governments couldn’t legally issue money anymore so they issued bearer bonds, a practice that lasted into the 1980s. Bearer bonds were liquid, scalable and backed by the reputation of the issuer rather than by gold, silver or the guarantee of a central bank.

Just like crypto.

Lesson unlearned

Fiat currency and bearer bonds existed side by side for decades. During that time, what most people now blindly accept as “money” had to compete. Federal Reserve notes were not inherently superior or more trusted than those of the Montana Territory, the Michigan Central Railroad or the Weehawken Ferry Co. The greenback had to prove itself in the marketplace, first against these non-fiat instruments, then against other national currencies once the gold standard came to an end in the early 1970s.

To be fair, the U.S. dollar emerged from the chaos of war mixed with inflation, imbalance of payments, foreign exchange speculation and strategic devaluation to be the world’s leading reserve currency. But that was then. We’re now in the 50th year of the post-Bretton Woods era – 1% of the entire history of money – and much has changed.

The reasons for the dollar’s success are fading. In 1960, America accounted for 40% of the world’s economic output; today it’s 24%. And while non-reserve currencies have done well to peg to the U.S. dollar, the other reserve currencies have always swung wildly against it. It has only been a relative “stablecoin,” if you will, against the yen and euro since 2014 and against the pound since 2017.

While that maps to the advent of cryptocurrencies, we mustn’t mistake coincidence with causality. The value of the entire space was still aspiring to breach $700 billion at the time, so its direct impact on the wealth of nations couldn’t possibly have been material. Still, it would be interesting to look into how simply the threat of emerging non-fiat currencies caused the major reserve currencies to narrow their trading bands.

Giving Davos its due

It’s a threat we now know monetary policy makers are taking seriously, with all the talk – and lately action – around central bank digital currencies (CBDC). China leads a list of more than 10 countries – including France, Canada and South Africa – piloting CBDCs. The monetary authorities in a handful of other countries are in the proof-of-concept phase, while much of the rest of the world, the U.S. included, is researching the feasibility of their own sovereign cryptocurrency.

The wisdom of this entire enterprise is questionable.

“While future proofs of concept may rely on different system designs, more experimentation and experience would be required before central banks can usefully and safely implement new technologies supporting a wholesale CBDC variant,” according to a Bank for International Settlements paper published in 2018, when this idea was still theoretical. “CBDC raises old questions about the role of central bank money, the scope of direct access to central bank liabilities and the structure of financial intermediation.”

Crypto enthusiasts rarely find agreement with the BIS, but every now and again they must tip their caps to the central banks’ central bank. “Old questions” must be asked anew.

How to do it better

Theoretically, there’s nothing inherently wrong with CBDCs. Yet, while they could eventually lead to more efficient payment processing throughout the economy, the potential cost to personal autonomy must be considered. If the Fed could trace every dollar bill you ever spent by tracking serial numbers, you’d have moved all your financial resources into privacy coins years ago. Of course, such tracking would be impractical. If the Fed were to issue a CBDC, though, that could suddenly become a standard procedure.

The currently available alternatives to fiat currencies are stablecoins. Still, they are unlikely, in their current form, to supplant government-issued money. Before they can, they need to provide the same full-faith-and-credit assurance provided by central bank notes.

“Creating a highly compliant blockchain could offer an alternative to state-backed blockchain initiatives such as CBDCs,” says Graeme Moore, head of tokenization for Polymath, a blockchain company that develops tools for regulated assets. “It’s important that innovators can continue to provide value for end consumers by providing them with options, while still maintaining regulatory compliance in an increasingly complex, global economy.”

Polymath is the company behind Polymesh, an institutional-grade permissioned blockchain built specifically for regulated assets. Polymesh builds on the widely popular ERC1400 standard to provide a compliance-focused blockchain.

Although the offering is initially focused on security tokens, Polymesh’s use case extends beyond security tokens into all regulated assets, with one of the most important being money. There’s no reason why the blockchain, built from the ground up, with compliance as a key design principle, can’t work for any instrument which requires regulatory compliance related to transfers, documentation, notification and fungibility.

Regulated assets, from money to securities, finally have a home on a blockchain purpose-built with regulatory compliance at its core.


Logo of BTCBTC$22,973.61
0.86%
Logo of ETHETH$1,636.25
0.62%
Logo of BNBBNB$328.73
1.29%
Logo of XRPXRP$0.39666156
0.79%
Logo of BUSDBUSD$0.99972975
0.00%

View All Prices

Sign up for State of Crypto, our weekly newsletter examining the intersection of cryptocurrency and government
By signing up, you will receive emails about CoinDesk product updates, events and marketing and you agree to our terms of services and privacy policy.

DISCLOSURE

Please note that our privacy policy, terms of use, cookies, and do not sell my personal information has been updated.

The leader in news and information on cryptocurrency, digital assets and the future of money, CoinDesk is a media outlet that strives for the highest journalistic standards and abides by a strict set of editorial policies. CoinDesk is an independent operating subsidiary of Digital Currency Group, which invests in cryptocurrencies and blockchain startups. As part of their compensation, certain CoinDesk employees, including editorial employees, may receive exposure to DCG equity in the form of stock appreciation rights, which vest over a multi-year period. CoinDesk journalists are not allowed to purchase stock outright in DCG.

CoinDesk - Unknown

CoinDesk Staff


Logo of BTCBTC$22,973.61
0.86%
Logo of ETHETH$1,636.25
0.62%
Logo of BNBBNB$328.73
1.29%
Logo of XRPXRP$0.39666156
0.79%
Logo of BUSDBUSD$0.99972975
0.00%

View All Prices
Coindesk Logo

About

AboutMastheadContributorsCareersCompany News

Stay Updated

ConsensusNewslettersFollow

Get In Touch

Contact UsAdvertiseAccessibility HelpSitemap

The Fine Print

Ethics PolicyPrivacyTerms Of UseDo Not Sell My Personal Information

Please note that our privacy policy, terms of use, cookies, and do not sell my personal information has been updated.

The leader in news and information on cryptocurrency, digital assets and the future of money, CoinDesk is a media outlet that strives for the highest journalistic standards and abides by a strict set of editorial policies. CoinDesk is an independent operating subsidiary of Digital Currency Group, which invests in cryptocurrencies and blockchain startups. As part of their compensation, certain CoinDesk employees, including editorial employees, may receive exposure to DCG equity in the form of stock appreciation rights, which vest over a multi-year period. CoinDesk journalists are not allowed to purchase stock outright in DCG.

©2022 CoinDesk

Twitter iconFacebook iconLinkedin iconRSS Logo
TikTokIcon