Even idle speculation that mysterious bitcoin founder Satoshi Nakamoto might be moving around a small batch of the cryptocurrency appeared sufficient to spook the market on Wednesday.
Bitcoin slid 2.3% on the day, retreating after a four-day rally and pushing the price down to about $9,500.
You're reading First Mover, CoinDesk's daily markets newsletter. Assembled by the CoinDesk Markets Team, First Mover starts your day with the most up-to-date sentiment around crypto markets, which of course never close, putting in context every wild swing in bitcoin and more. We follow the money so you don’t have to. You can subscribe here.
But earlier in the day, bitcoin plunged as low as $9,100 after the Twitter account “Whale Alert” sent a message indicating a recent transfer of 40 bitcoins, worth some $391,055, might be from a "possible #Satoshi owned wallet" that had lain dormant since the first few months of 2009 - soon after bitcoin itself had launched.
Shortly afterward, on Wednesday, the same address transferred 10 more coins over the blockchain.
Satoshi wrote the white paper that mapped out the framework and rules for the bitcoin blockchain, but disappeared soon after the protocol launched, and their identity has never officially been confirmed. Many believe the name was a pseudonym.
The reason it matters to digital-asset traders is that Satoshi — whoever he, she or they may be — is assumed to have amassed a large amount of bitcoins from mining shortly after the protocol’s launch in early 2009.
Of course, a bitcoin transfer doesn't necessarily indicate anything has been sold, and there are strong indications the address might not even be connected to the enigmatic founder.
But one fear could be that if Satoshi — or whoever it is behind the account — starts selling in large amounts, it could theoretically put downward pressure on the price.
"No matter who moved the coins, it did cause a mean ol' nasty spike on the charts," wrote Mati Greenspan, founder of foreign exchange and cryptocurrency research firm Quantum Economics, in an e-mail to clients.
According to the cryptocurrency security researcher Sergio Demian Lerner, Satoshi's untouched hoard might include as many as one million bitcoins, though BitMEX Research has estimated the number could be closer to 700,000.
Movement from old, inactive bitcoins is notable since such events rarely happen.
In fact, the 50 coins at the focus of Wednesday's speculation — from data block 3,654, versus more than 631,000 now — were the first inactive coins mined in early 2009 to move since August 2017, according to data shared on Twitter by Coin Metrics engineer Antoine Le Calvez.
“This occurrence highlights the importance of ‘address watching,'" Jose Llisterri, co-founder of crypto trading platform Interdax, told CoinDesk's Daniel Cawrey. That includes "monitoring the addresses of whales/early miners and the so-called ‘Satoshi coins’ mined in the first months of bitcoin."
But there are strong indications the coins might not actually belong to Satoshi.
The primary evidence linking them to bitcoin’s creator are that the coins were mined in 2009, when few people were involved in the network, and that they've been inactive ever since.
But Lerner, the cryptocurrency security researcher, identified a unique “Patoshi pattern” in April 2019 that appears in the hash rate of a single, early miner. The assumption is the miner was likely Satoshi.
Lerner has identified all of those data blocks, and the 50 coins moved on Wednesday weren't among them.
Some bitcoiners immediately panned the Whale Alert's suggestion.
“Y'all need to up your analysis game,” Jameson Lopp, chief technology officer at bitcoin custody provider Casa, tweeted at the Whale Alert account.
In response to questions sent via Twitter, Whale Alert tweeted back that the "chance that this wallet is associated with Satoshi himself given its age and the transactions itself was interesting enough to post."
"We are aware of the Patoshi research, but unlike what some are saying, we do not feel it excludes the possibility that Satoshi was the owner of those coins," Whale Alert wrote via a direct message.
Another angle is the vintage bitcoins might have been transferred by an early bitcoiner who has been active all along — just buying and selling newer bitcoins. So the fact the earliest coins were transferred might not mean the owner is suddenly doing anything differently.
Gregory Maxwell, prominent Bitcoin Core developer and Blockstream co-founder, took to Reddit on Wednesday to explain that certain characteristics of the bitcoin protocol could cause coins like these to be left inactive in an otherwise active wallet owned by the same entity.
“It's possible that the author of this transaction has been frequently active all along, and their wallet just got around to spending this particular coin,” said Maxwell. From his perspective, he said, “nothing connects these coins to Satoshi.”
The takeaway for traders is to be on the lookout for vintage bitcoins — whether they're Satoshi Nakamoto's or not.
Tweet of the day
BTC: Price: $9,349 (BPI) | 24-Hr High: $9,795 | 24-Hr Low: $9,235
Trend: Bitcoin is facing selling pressure on Thursday amid bearish developments on short-duration technical charts.
The top cryptocurrency by market value is currently trading at $9,360, representing a 1.7% decline on the day, having spent the first half of the week battling selling pressure near $10,000.
Prices fell by over $600 to $9,100 on Wednesday, confirming an ascending triangle breakdown on the hourly chart. The pattern indicates the rally from the low of $8,100 observed ahead of bitcoin's May 11 halving has ended, and the bears have regained control.
The bearish view has been reinforced by rejection at $9,600 (lower high) seen during the Asian trading hours and the subsequent drop to levels below $9,400. Further, the MACD histogram is again producing deeper bars below the zero line, indicating strengthening of bearish momentum.
As a result, the path of least resistance appears to be on the downside. Some observers may suggest otherwise, as the daily chart is reporting a golden crossover - a bull cross of the 50- and 200-day averages. However, the so-called long-term bull market indicator is based on historical data and often traps buyers on the wrong side of the market. "The last time the 50 DMA crossed above the 200 DMA, there was a 60%+ drop in price over the next month," tweeted popular analyst Josh Rager.
The immediate support is seen at $9,000, which, if breached, would open the doors to the four-hour chart 200-candle average at $8,590. On the higher side, key resistances are located at $9,600 (the Asian session high) and $10,000, which has proved a tough nut to crack over the past few days.
The leader in news and information on cryptocurrency, digital assets and the future of money, CoinDesk is an award-winning media outlet that strives for the highest journalistic standards and abides by a strict set of editorial policies. In November 2023, CoinDesk was acquired by Bullish group, owner of Bullish, a regulated, institutional digital assets exchange. Bullish group is majority owned by Block.one; both groups have interests in a variety of blockchain and digital asset businesses and significant holdings of digital assets, including bitcoin. CoinDesk operates as an independent subsidiary, and an editorial committee, chaired by a former editor-in-chief of The Wall Street Journal, is being formed to support journalistic integrity.