UPDATE: MakerDAO token holders have now voted to increase the DAI Stability Fee to 11.5 percent.
Investors who hold tokens in the programmatic lending protocol MakerDAO appear likely to approve a fifth fee increase that would further raise the cost of platform's US dollar-backed stablecoin DAI.
Since Monday, five different options have been presented to MakerDAO token holders, all of which suggested different possible increases to the platform's "stability fee," the most extreme being a 4 percent increase. This preliminary round of polling has now ended and token holders look set to ratify that change in a final executive vote.
Once ratified, the 11.5 percent stability fee will make it more expensive for users to take out programmatic loans of DAI by locking up ether as collateral.
The aim is to reduce the amount of DAI in the markets and push up the stablecoin's value, which currently hovers at $0.96, a figure that's below the stable $1 price developers and users want to achieve.
As noted by MakerDAO Foundation risk management lead Cyrus Younessi during a public call Thursday:
The news comes despite a 4 percent fee hike executed just last month and three other, smaller increases that have been approved and implemented to the code since February.
Reducing DAI supply
Yet, with all increases having proved ineffective in stabilizing the DAI peg, some users are now calling for a different approach to reducing circulating DAI supply.
"At some point soon, it may make sense to lay off the [stability fee] hikes and rely on the 100 million supply cap to restore order," writes Ryan Sean Adams, founder of crypto asset investment company MythosCapital, on Reddit.
This suggestion to change the hard supply cap of 100 million DAI was also raised as a point of discussion in today's MakerDAO governance and risk call.
"I'd say if we don't see an improvement in the DAI price by next week we consider reducing the debt ceiling in addition to a [stability fee] raise," wrote Matthew Light in the call chatroom.
Currently, only 100 million DAI can be loaned out to users in exchange for ETH. The eventual plan is to introduce multi-collateral DAI whereby users can take out new DAI by putting up holdings of a variety of different cryptocurrencies – not just ETH – each with a unique "debt ceiling."
"The debt ceiling should primarily reflect the extent to which [the MakerDAO system] is willing to generate DAI off of this collateral," explained Younessi on today's call. "It should be constrained by the liquidity of the underlying asset."
As such, Younessi added that changing the debt ceiling for DAI – presently backed only by ETH and with a hard supply cap of 100 million as a result – in his view was "not a great idea."
"MakerDAO should want to accommodate as much debt ceiling and DAI generation as possible barring risk of collateral failing for the system. Messing with the DAI ceiling to affect the price of DAI seems like not the right approach," said Younessi.
Echoing Younessi's hesitation, call participant Lawson Baker called instead for more aggressive and dynamic fee hikes.
"Using the DAI supply cap/debt ceiling is the functional equivalent of shutting down your app for new users. This is a bad idea ... Increase the costs until [user demand] slows enough to stabilize the system." wrote Baker in today's call chatroom.
For now, as stated by MakerDAO Foundation head of community development Richard Brown, the plan is to move into "a process of continuous polling."
"The idea now is that every week we come out with the same options [for Stability Fee increases]," explained Brown on the call. "We do that until what I'm assuming in the happy, happy future we decide this is slightly onerous and unnecessary."
For this to work, Brown emphasized the importance of continued voter turnout by holders of the MakerDAO governance token each week until DAI peg stability is restored.
"Signaling is paramount," said Brown. "Even if you're not going to move the needle, signaling any support of one of these options is an amazingly important data point."
Calling the end of today's community vote "potentially one of the records for voter turnout" with 64 voters in total signaling for another four percent fee increase, Brown emphasized:
Pennies image via Shutterstock
CoinDesk is an award-winning media outlet that covers the cryptocurrency industry. Its journalists abide by a strict set of editorial policies. In November 2023, CoinDesk was acquired by the Bullish group, owner of Bullish, a regulated, digital assets exchange. The Bullish group is majority-owned by Block.one; both companies have interests in a variety of blockchain and digital asset businesses and significant holdings of digital assets, including bitcoin. CoinDesk operates as an independent subsidiary with an editorial committee to protect journalistic independence. CoinDesk offers all employees above a certain salary threshold, including journalists, stock options in the Bullish group as part of their compensation.