Social media has been abuzz since Tuesday’s initial sale of the forthcoming Venezuelan government-backed cryptocurrency, the petro, though reviews are so far mixed.
So far, Venezuelan president Nicolas Maduro has claimed that the country had collected a whopping $735 million during the first day of its presale for the new cryptocurrency. In spite of a lack of proof, the claim came amid a splashy, nationally-televised broadcast where Maduro himself declared that the country has “taken a giant step into the 21st century.”
Venezuela’s government first unveiled the petro back in December, setting up a dedicated government agency to oversee the development of the project and build up an ecosystem for it within the South American nation. In anticipation of the sale, the government published a white paper, a buyer’s guide and, most recently, newly crafted rules for creating cryptocurrency exchanges within Venezuela.
The initiative has sparked a range of tweets in support – and in opposition – to the idea, buoyed by a dedicated hashtag, #AlFuturoConElPetro (which translates to “to the future with the petro”).
For instance, one advocate tweeted, “The new economic era for Venezuela begins. The newborn criptomoneda called el petro has many challenges ahead, but its armoring will be the potential for the progressive regularization of the economy.”
Perhaps unsurprisingly, members of the country’s National Assembly – which is controlled by political parties in opposition to Maduro – have blasted the move, including in statements issued just hours after Tuesday’s broadcast event.
Among those taking a public stance against the petro is Marialbert Barrios, a National Assembly deputy who asked: “Who in their right mind buys a [cryptocurrency] from a government that does not pay the foreign debt, with an economy in hyperinflation?”
¡Ahora van a querer pagar las deudas con “petros”! para tratar de darle vida a ese invento que en verdad es una emisión de deuda externa sin autorización de la @AsambleaVE. ¡Cuidado con los vendedores de humo!
— Marialbert Barrios (@MarialbertBs) February 21, 2018
The pushback from the Assembly comes amid an acute political standoff between opposition forces and the Maduro government. According to Reuters, opposition parties are expected to boycott an upcoming presidential election in April, which they argue is rigged in Maduro’s favor.
Deputy Rafael Guzman called the cryptocurrency “fraudulent,” reiterating past arguments that it will fuel illegal activity.
“[The] petro is a fraudulent, illegal and invalid mechanism for the government to continue its shady business and money laundering, because it is not known where those resources will come from,” he wrote.
Base of support
In contrast with the denunciations from the opposition-controlled Assembly, various offices within the Venezuelan government have used their social media presences to boost agencies that promote the petro.
Among those is SENIAT, Venezuela’s tax and revenue authority, which claimed that residents can use the petro to pay their tax liabilities, among other things.
El Petro será canjeable por dinero fiduciario y otros criptoactivos a través de casas de cambio digitales. El Estado aceptará el pago de impuestos, obligaciones, tasas, contribuciones y servicios públicos nacionales en Petro. #AlFuturoConElPetro pic.twitter.com/80puSYsmbb
— SENIAT (@SENIAT_Oficial) February 21, 2018
“The state will accept the payment of national taxes, duties, fees, contributions and public services in petro,” the agency wrote.
“This initiative, this new South, gives us an endless range of options and opportunities in the national and international market, opening new Horizons that have no limits,” she wrote.
Other tweets in support of the move include those from the Venezuelan consulates in Hong Kong and Vancouver.
Maduro’s official Twitter account has seen a number of related posts in the past day, including one from Wednesday afternoon that played back footage from Tuesday’s broadcast.
Estamos dando un paso gigante hacia la nueva economía y el futuro. ¡Sintámonos orgullosos del nacimiento del Petro! En los meses que están por venir, el Pueblo tiene una cita con la prosperidad… Con la victoria. #AlFuturoConElPetro pic.twitter.com/G7S1XoVSQt
— Nicolás Maduro (@NicolasMaduro) February 21, 2018
Local bitcoiners raise concerns
Yet, turning back to the opposition, politicians in Venezuela aren’t the only ones pushing back against the idea.
While the skepticism voiced by Venezuelan opposition lawmakers could be seen through the lens of the ongoing political crisis in the country, the critiques put forward by members of the local bitcoin and cryptocurrency community are more nuanced and focused on the fact that the Maduro government will likely wield significant control over the cryptocurrency it’s creating.
In a post on a local Facebook group, one commentator wrote that it is “really worrying” that the government would exercise such a large degree of control, especially considering the wide-reaching push for people to start using it.
The fear, he said, is that the government will have “the absolute power to manipulate and adulterate the blockchain at will over petro.”
Others aruged the petro isn’t much of a decentralized cryptocurrency at all. “That’s what makes the petro a debt bond and not a crypto in itself, plus the danger of these guys behind that project,” one community member wrote.
Yet another observer offered a broader take, posting in the Facebook thread:
“Tyranny is that: [a] monopoly of power in the hands of a political class that only cares about its space.”
Editor’s Note: Statements in this report have been translated from Spanish.
Image via the Bitcoin Venezuela Facebook Group