Bitcoin in the Headlines is a weekly look at bitcoin news, analyzing media and its impact.
Despite featuring its fair share of salacious material – including the run-up to the sentencing in the Ross Ulbricht trial, this week's news cycle was perhaps more mature in its assessment of bitcoin as a financial technology.
Spurred by the inclusion of former US Department of Treasury Secretary Lawrence Summers to Xapo's board of directors, more enterprising journalists sought to venture into topics that aimed to illuminate debates on bitcoin as a monetary system.
Arguments centered largely on whether bitcoin represents a truly unique breakthrough in the history of money, one that can only be compared to disruptive technologies like the Internet, or whether it is a passing fad, one that, despite promise, is doomed to repeat past mistakes.
Summers meets magnifying glass
Kaminska made her opinion of the company known, chiding Xapo for its business model. A specialist in deep cold storage, Xapo uses a process by which bitcoins are kept secure in reinforced underground bunkers with all manner of military-grade protections.
Here, Kaminska reintroduces the idea that bitcoin is a speculative bubble that will eventually deflate, one akin to the 'tulip mania' of the 1600s where the value of tulips skyrocketed, only to again fall.
Using past statements, Kaminska aimed to suggest that Summers should perhaps be against the idea that bitcoins could have lasting value.
Kaminska cites Summers' statement in the Financial Times from last year, in which he is quoted as saying:
Summers himself has presented mixed views on bitcoin in public appearances. For example, Summers has sought to portray the payments network as one that requires the help of regulation to succeed.
Further, much of his praise for bitcoin seems based in its comparison to the Internet, which he noted was also roundly dismissed in its early days.
Still, this didn't stop Kaminska from poking fun at Summers' appointment to the company's board.
"You might as well sit on the advisory boards of the companies pumping [bubbles] so as to advise and steer them?" she concluded.
Speculation on speculation
Elsewhere, the evolution of the bitcoin economy was discussed by Barry Silbert, founder of Digital Currency Group and a noted early-stage investor in bitcoin startups.
Speaking to Entrepreneur, during the Inside Bitcoins Conference in New York last month, Silbert discussed whether he felt bitcoin could become a stable form of money, or rather, how it could develop into a perhaps more mature means of value exchange.
Silbert added that he believes bitcoin must still be "established as a form of value", suggesting that this evolution will likely take place over time.
"For bitcoin to be a global currency the volatility has to decrease or we need to hedge out risk," he said.
Silbert's statements follow Bloomberg's Bitcoin Brief, released last week. The report, to which Silbert contributed, tackled the question of how speculation is affecting the bitcoin economy, suggesting that this is perhaps holding back bitcoin from becoming a true digital currency.
"There's a rule in economics called Gresham's law, which is that when you have two currencies, people tend to hoard the one with greater material value and spend the one with less material value," it reads, continuing:
"This makes it more difficult for bitcoin to establish itself as a medium of exchange, because no one wants to actually spend them," concluded the report.
A question of worth
Linking into the debate, Forbes, a regular in this weekly series, re-posted a Quora piece with the following headline "Is the Price of Bitcoin Going to Bounce Back?"
The piece again takes on the question of how the health of bitcoin's economy should be assessed.
"Given that the price of bitcoin is determined solely by supply and demand, and that the supply of new bitcoins is predetermined, with new coins being issued steadily at a rate that drops sharply in the future, the only variable of interest is demand."
The piece continued:
The article seemed less positive with regard's to the digital currency's potential, at least today, arguing that there has been little evidence to suggest the technology is mature enough to compete against traditional financial incumbents.
"To somebody who already has access to modern financial tools like bank accounts and credit cards, these are very few new things bitcoin has to offer," the report read. "The compelling uses for bitcoin so far are to serve as a vehicle for speculation [...] and as a method of gambling and making purchases on the dark markets".
Pete Rizzo contributed reporting.
Newspaper image via Shutterstock
The leader in news and information on cryptocurrency, digital assets and the future of money, CoinDesk is a media outlet that strives for the highest journalistic standards and abides by a strict set of editorial policies. CoinDesk is an independent operating subsidiary of Digital Currency Group, which invests in cryptocurrencies and blockchain startups. As part of their compensation, certain CoinDesk employees, including editorial employees, may receive exposure to DCG equity in the form of stock appreciation rights, which vest over a multi-year period. CoinDesk journalists are not allowed to purchase stock outright in DCG.