This past fall, I wrote about the idea that, while much of the rhetoric around cryptocurrencies has to do with “decentralization” as a guiding ethos, the NFT sector is in fact already extremely centralized.
Specifically, it’s centralized on the sales side. According to data from the blockchain analytics company DappRadar, the vast majority of all non-fungible token sales volume is concentrated on two platforms: OpenSea, the incumbent backed by venture capital firm Andreessen Horowitz, and LooksRare, a scrappy outsider that emerged a few months ago. But because the vast majority of sales volume on LooksRare comes from “wash trades” – that is, traders selling themselves their own NFTs in an attempt to take advantage of the platform’s token rewards system – it’s safe to say that what you might call real NFT trades are happening almost entirely on OpenSea.
This article is excerpted from The Node, CoinDesk's daily roundup of the most pivotal stories in blockchain and crypto news. You can subscribe to get the full newsletter here.
And although that’s still very much the case, the NFT market has recently begun a kind of second-order centralization in the realm of content.
On Friday evening, Yuga Labs, the company behind the Bored Ape Yacht Club NFT collection, announced it had acquired the “brands, copyright in the art and other IP rights” for two NFT projects from the developer Larva Labs: CryptoPunks, the pixelated mug shots that helped elevate NFTs into the public consciousness last year, and Meebits, their 3D counterparts.
CryptoPunks were the world’s most valuable NFTs for most of 2021, until Bored Apes dethroned them.
On one level, the acquisition makes sense. Larva Labs has always been just two guys, John Watkinson and Matt Hall. They created CryptoPunks back in 2017, essentially as an experiment. As hype built around their project in 2020 and 2021, the duo kept on working their day jobs at the Google Creative Lab in Manhattan, where their co-workers wondered why they weren’t off capitalizing on the crypto gold rush. They kept on experimenting, launching Meebits last May, but they never really decided to make CryptoPunks their full-time focus.
As time went on, this hands-off approach to the CryptoPunks' intellectual property began to annoy some CryptoPunk investors. Today, mostly thanks to the success of the Bored Ape Yacht Club business model, the expectation for major NFT collections is that they will function like online social clubs, hosting lavish invite-only concerts and in-person meetups, as well as spinoff NFT projects with the potential to spawn their own communities. Bored Ape holders were signing with major record labels and agencies – where were the equivalent perks for CryptoPunks?
The implication was that CryptoPunks didn’t need that social apparatus. For the Bored Ape Yacht Club, the “community” element has always been a key part of the value proposition – you’re supposed to wear those hoodies, attend those parties. CryptoPunks were initially conceived as pure collectibles; organic speculation, rather than a coordinated marketing campaign, was what made the price go up.
Watkinson and Hall managed to capture lighting in a bottle. Meanwhile, Yuga Labs has reportedly been in talks with Andreessen Horowitz about funding that would value it at $5 billion. The undisclosed sum collected by Larva Labs may have been too good to resist.
The result is that the two most valuable NFT collections are now owned by a single company we know relatively little about. We only just learned the names of its executive leadership last month, in a report from BuzzFeed News (Yuga Labs’ two core founders had previously been pseudonymous, and put up a fight after what they saw as a “dangerous” act of journalism on the part of BuzzFeed).
Larva Labs remains an independent company and retains the rights to its other major NFT project, Autoglyphs. And Yuga Labs has said it doesn’t have any immediate plans to replicate the Bored Apes business model with CryptoPunks, which a press release characterized as a “historic collection.”
Instead, Yuga Labs plans to add “utility” to the collection. “Utility” is an increasingly nebulous buzzword in the NFT sector, and tends to refer to perks for investors down the line. If your NFT unlocks access to a private Discord channel, or to a pre-approved green list for another NFT mint, or a special 3D item on a metaverse platform – broadly speaking, that’s “utility.” (Utility also has the potential to bring certain tokens under scrutiny from the SEC, since it can make NFTs look a lot like investment contracts.)
Read More: ENS and the Limitations of DAO Governance
What this means in practice is that the value of CryptoPunks will likely be closely tied to the value of Yuga Labs. Larva Labs isn’t exactly a mom-and-pop business, but its stubborn refusal to pump the value of its tokens in this specific way put it somewhat at odds with the “number go up” ethos of the broader crypto community. (This isn’t to say its intentions were always totally pure – a controversy around a CryptoPunks subcollection known as “V1 Punks” suggests the Larva Labs team hasn’t always handled community outreach in the best way.)
Where Bored Apes go, the rest of the NFT market goes. Now, whether they like it or not, CryptoPunk holders are joined at the hip with their Bored Ape counterparts.
Such is the Matroyshka doll-like structure of the NFT market. Andreessen Horowitz has a stake in many of the valuable companies in crypto; OpenSea, an Andreessen Horowitz investment, controls most of the volume in the NFT market; and Yuga Labs, also reportedly an Andreessen Horowitz investment, now controls some of the market’s most valuable intellectual property.
There’s no antitrust legislation in crypto – but maybe that’s the point.
Learn more about Consensus 2023, CoinDesk’s longest-running and most influential event that brings together all sides of crypto, blockchain and Web3. Head to consensus.coindesk.com to register and buy your pass now.
The leader in news and information on cryptocurrency, digital assets and the future of money, CoinDesk is a media outlet that strives for the highest journalistic standards and abides by a strict set of editorial policies. CoinDesk is an independent operating subsidiary of Digital Currency Group, which invests in cryptocurrencies and blockchain startups. As part of their compensation, certain CoinDesk employees, including editorial employees, may receive exposure to DCG equity in the form of stock appreciation rights, which vest over a multi-year period. CoinDesk journalists are not allowed to purchase stock outright in DCG.