Jihan Wu, co-founder and former co-CEO of crypto mining giant Bitmain, is arguing that ASIC miners make blockchain networks more decentralized – a position that counters the prevailing opinion of developers who see specialized miners as a force that excludes broad participation in the competition for mining rewards.
Speaking at a keynote during a blockchain event hosted by a crypto media outlet Mars Finance in Chongqing, China, on Wednesday, Wu told attendees he believes ASIC miners – powerful processors designed for crunching specific algorithms – are less of a centralizing force than more general purpose graphics processing units (GPUs) that are also commonly used as an alternative for cryptocurrency mining.
The discussion also led Wu to cast doubts on ethereum’s coming ProgPow upgrade (for Programmatic Proof-of-Work), which, by altering the network’s mining algorithm, is designed to block ASIC machines and improve the computing advantage of GPUs.
He told the audience:
“While we have seen various network upgrades that aim to become ASIC-resistant, such as Cuckoo cycle and ProgPow, but what we can foresee is that, very likely, there will still be ASIC miners for these two algorithms.”
Recently, the ethereum community voted to approve the network’s ProgPow upgrade. However, the timeline for activation is not confirmed yet, as a period is needed for auditing the code. It’s a change that, if activated, could have an impact on ethereum’s mining rewards – a market that’s estimated to be worth over $600 million a year.
Wu added that the ethereum network is already centralized to some extent, pointing to statistics that two major ethereum mining pools – Sparkpool and Ethermine – control over half of the network’s computing power.
He further cited rumors, without providing any evidence, that certain individuals involved in the ProgPow proposal directly report to the CEO of NVIDIA, a major maker of GPU hardware with a dominant market share.
“To me, ProgPow is clearly an effort to achieve centralization, in an attempt to exclude other integrated circuit designers to participate in ethereum mining. And GPU hardware is strongly protected by patents, so having a tailor-made algorithm for this type of hardware is certainly a way to avoid a fully competitive market.”
Switching from the proof-of-work algorithm, as used by ethereum currently, to proof-of-stake (supporting a network by holding a stake of its native tokens) will not solve the problem of centralization for ethereum either, Wu contended. If ethereum completely shifts to proof-of-stake, “the entire network will be even more centralized – almost undoubtedly,” he argued.
Yet, Wu’s comments on ethereum mining may not be entirely surprising given that his firm, which claims to own about 70 percent of the global crypto mining equipment market share, launched an ethereum ASIC miner in April of last year.
Bitmain once also secured a patent for its ASIC miner equipment design and subsequently sued one of its rivals for IP infringement. The case was dismissed by a local court in China, however, and Bitmain’s patent was revoked as a result.
Elsewhere in his speech, Wu also argued that ASIC miners are more capable of securing a blockchain network than GPU hardware. Because each ASIC is specialized for a certain crypto network, they bring a high cost for bad actors wanting to launch a 51 percent attack on a network.
“But GPU-based mining algorithms are not specialized, they are compatible with each other. If miners attack one cryptocurrency, there are still others that can be mined. That’s why there’re more 51 percent attacks on GPU-based cryptos.”
Correction (May 15, 2020, 18:51 UTC): ProgPoW stands for programmatic proof-of-work, not progressive proof-of-work, as was previously listed in this article.
Jihan Wu image via Wolfie Zhao for CoinDesk
The leader in blockchain news, CoinDesk is a media outlet that strives for the highest journalistic standards and abides by a strict set of editorial policies. CoinDesk is an independent operating subsidiary of Digital Currency Group, which invests in cryptocurrencies and blockchain startups.