Dutch Central Bank: Bitcoin 'No Viable Alternative' to Fiat Currency
The Dutch central bank, De Nederlandsche Bank (DNB), has issued a warning on digital currencies such as bitcoin, saying that they "are unlikely to become a viable alternative for traditional currency in the foreseeable future".
Recognising that digital currencies fall outside the bank's scope for regulation, the statement on the DNB website warns:
"There is also no security in respect of funds received, ie no guarantee that balances will be returned following bankruptcy, and outstanding payments will be executed. No-one monitors whether virtual currency institutions have sound and responsible business operations."
Measured but negative
Back in December 2013, the former president of the DNB, Nout Wellink, dismissed bitcoin, saying that the “façade” and hype around the currency would eventually fade – likening it to the 'Tulip Mania' of the 17th century.
In April the deputy director of the Dutch Payments Association, while making the same 'Tulip Mania' comparison, claimed digital currencies were technology but not money.
However, this latest statement is more measured, giving an overview of how digital currencies work, including mining, before warning:
"There is a lot of interest in virtual currencies, owing to their innovative character and their way of challenging the current financial system, but this does not make them a viable alternative for the basic functions of money."
As with many similar bank warnings, the organisation is concerned about the absence of a central authority overseeing the bitcoin industry, with "market players in virtual currency systems [providing] only weak security guarantees".
Theft and compliance
The security of users' funds are also a threat, the bank says, with the spectre of Mt. Gox’s bankruptcy raised as a case in point:
"[...] virtual currency systems are definitely still falling short where security is concerned. Due to its decentralised set-up, there is no central party in the virtual currency world that has the responsibility to hold market players to account when they fail to comply with conditions for use, security demands, or legal frameworks."
A further element of the DNB warning is that virtual currencies are still not widely used, due to their disadvantages. Currently, there are less than 1,000 transactions per day in the Netherlands, compared with over 16 million euro payments.
Issues for users
Along with the standard threat of bitcoin's volatility and security problems, the DNB raises doubts about the reliability of the software used in digital currency transactions, saying:
"The software supporting a virtual currency system may be faulty, meaning that the integrity of transactions cannot be guaranteed."
One of the attractions of bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies is that it is extremely cheap to carry out a transaction compared with traditional financial systems, such as international bank transfers.
However, the central bank warns that this will not be the case in the long term and raises the spectre of high fees as bitcoin reaches its built-in production limit:
"[...] when the majority of the maximum number of 21 million bitcoins will have been created around 2030, transaction processing costs will have to be recovered from transaction fees. The current low fees are then unlikely to be maintained."
Jelmer Baukema, a lawyer working at Van Doorne NV, Amsterdam, and who specializes in working with digital currencies, said:
"I think [the bank's statement] will not affect the Dutch bitcoin system, as the DNB did not explicitly express its disapproval against the use of bitcoin. The bank seems, at least for the moment, to be playing down the role of bitcoin in the Dutch economy (rightly or wrongly)."
Baukema said that, besides this official statement, there have been a number of unofficial statements from DNB, saying that it exercises, or will exercise, supervision on companies that conduct bitcoin-related activities (such as 'third-party bitcoin services') where, for example, fiat currencies are being held on behalf of third parties.
In addition, he said, the DNB may be planning an official report on bitcoin in the near future.
"In general, this DNB statement on bitcoin is very limited and its contents do not provide new insights on how bitcoin related activities are, or will be, regulated or supervised in the Netherlands," Baukema concluded.
Bitcoin economy thriving
Despite the less-than-positive signals from the Netherlands' banking world, bitcoin is seeing something of a boom in the country, with the Bitcoin 2014 Conference scheduled to take place in Amsterdam next week.
In March, CoinDesk reported how 10 Dutch businesses lining two canal-side streets took the collective decision to band together to accept bitcoin, becoming the country's first 'Bitcoin Boulevard'.
Furthermore, Hollands’ biggest food delivery network now accepts bitcoin, as does one of the country's high-profile lawyers. Dutch bitcoiners can even book a helicopter flight with digital currency, too.
Mt. Gox Revival Plan Granted Preliminary Nod of Approval
Bitcoin Foundation Announces Blockchain Awards Shortlist